Metaphilosophy of the Life-world

Sellars, Husserl, and the quantum image of nature

Authors

  • Danilo Manca

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.4454/philinq.v10i1.387

Keywords:

Husserl, Sellars, scientific realism, life-world, quantum physics, nature

Abstract

The aim of this article is to assess whether the notion of “life-world” could be helpful for a philosophical theory that assigns a primacy to the scientific view of the world when it comes to establish what exists. I set out to integrate the concept of “life-world” as understood in Husserl’s late phenomenology with the point of view defended by Sellars in Philosophy and the Scientific Image of Man in the World. In what follows, I will consider the image of nature proposed by the standard “Copenhagen” version of quantum physics. This will allow me to challenge Sellars’s assumptions that reality cannot be conceived as stratified, and that the term “phenomenon” has to be meant as “illusory appearance” in a supposedly Kantian sense. At the same time, I will discuss Husserl’s conviction that the ‘technization’ of science entails a philosophical loss of meaning of the scientific image of the world.

References

Argentieri, Niccolò, 2009, Ci sono elettroni nel mondo-della-vita? Esperienza, matematica, realtà: una lettura fenomenologica dell’epistemologia di Werner Heisenberg, Bonanno, Acireale-Roma.

Bell, John Stewart, 2004, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Bernet, Rudolf, Kern, Iso, and Marbach, Eduard, 1989, Edmund Husserl: Darstellung seines Denken, Meiner Verlag, Hamburg; Eng. tr. with a foreword by Lester Embree, An introduction to Husserlian Phenomenology, Northwestern University Press, Evanston (IL), 1993.

Bitbol, Michel, 2020, “A Phenomenological Ontology for Physics: Merleau-Ponty and QBism”, in Wiltsche, Berghofer 2020: 227-242.

Bohm, David, 1952, “A Suggested Interpretation of Quantum Theory in Terms of ‘Hidden’ Variables”, in Physical Review, 85: 166-192.

Bohr, Niels 1981: Collected Works, general editor Léon Rosenfeld, vol. 2: Work on Atomic Physics (1912-1917), ed. by Ulrich Hoyer, North-Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam/New York/Oxford.

Born, Max, 1926, “Zur Quantenmechanik der Stossvorgänge”, in Zeitschrift für Physik, 37: 863-867, eng. tr.: “On the quantum mechanics of collisions”, in Wheeler, Zurek 1983: 52-61.

Born, Max, Heisenberg, Werner, and Jordan, Paul, 1926, “Zur Quantenmechanik II”, in Zeitschrift für Physik, 35: 557-615; Eng. tr.: “On quantum mechanics II”, in Van der Waerden 1967: 321-385.

Born, Max, and Jordan, Paul, 1925, “Zur Quantenmechanik”, in Zeitschrift für Physik, 34: 858-888; partial Eng. tr.: “On quantum mechanics II”, in Van der Waerden 1967: 277-306.

Cappelletti, Valentina, 2001, Dall’ordine alle cose. Saggio su Werner Heisenberg, Jaca Book, Milano.

Christias, Dionysis, 2020, “Lifeworld Phenomenology and Science”, in Manca and Nunziante 2020: 261-286.

Christias, Dionysis, 2018, “Sellars’ Naturalism, the Myth of the Given and Husserl’s Transcendental Phenomenology”, The Philosophical Forum 49: 511-539.

De Broglie, Louis, 1925, “Recherches sur la théorie des Quanta”, in Annales de Physique, 3/III (Janvrier-Février): 3-128.

De La Tremblaye, Laura, 2020, “QBism from a Phenomenological Point of View: Husserl and QBism”, Wiltsche, Berghofer 2020: 243-260.

De Santis, Daniele, 2019, “Méditations Hégéliennes vs. Méditations Cartésiennes: Edmund Husserl and Wilfrid Sellars on the Given”, in A. Ferrarin, D. Moran, E. Magrì, and D. Manca eds., Hegel and Phenomenology, Springer, Cham: 177-190.

Dirac, Paul, 1928, “The Quantum Theory of Electrons”, in Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character, 117/778 (Feb. 1): 610-624.

Einstein, Albert, 1931, “Maxwell’s Influence on the Development of the Conception of Physical Reality”, in James Clerk Maxwell, A Commemoration Volume 1831-1931, with essays by Joseph John Thomson, Max Planck, Albert Einstein and others, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge: 66-73.

Einstein, Albert, 1905, “Über einen die Erzeugung und Verwandlung des Lichtes betreffenden heuristischen Gesichtspunkt”, in Annalen der Physik, 322/6: 132-148, eng. tr.: “Concerning an Heuristic Point of View Toward the Emission and Transformation of Light”, in American Journal of Physics, 33/5, May 1965: 367-374.

Einstein, Albert, Born, Max and Hedwig, 1971, The Born-Einstein Letters. Correspondence from 1916 to 1955, with commentaries by M. Born, introduction by Werner Heinsenberg, foreword by Bertrand Russell, Eng. tr. Irene Born, Macmillan, London and Basingstoke.

Einstein, Albert, Podolsky, Boris, Rosen, Nathan 1935, “Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?”, in Physical Review, 47/10: 777-780.

Feynman, Richard P., 2010, Lectures on Physics. The New Millennium Edition, vol. I: Mainly Mechanics, Radiation, and Heat, Basic Books, New York.

Feynman, Richard P., 2006, The Character of Physical Law, Penguin Books, London.

Feynman, Richard P., 1983, QED. The strange theory of light and matter, Princeton University Press, Princeton (NJ).

French, 2002, “A phenomenological solution to the measurement problem? Husserl and the foundations of quantum mechanics”, in Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 33: 467-491.

French, 2020, “From a lost history to a New Future: Is a Phenomenological Approach to Quantum Physics viable?”, in Wiltsche and Berghofer 2020: 205-224.

Greene, Brian, 1999, The Elegant Universe: Superstrings, Hidden Dimensions, and the Quest for the Ultimate Theory, W. W. Norton & Co. Inc., New York.

Heisenberg, Werner, 2000 [1958], Physics and philosophy, Penguin, London.

Heisenberg, Werner, 1994, Ordnung der Wirklichkeit, Piper Verlag, Münich; Eng. tr. by Martin B. Rumscheidt, Nancy Lukens and Irene Heisenberg, ed. by K. Kleinknecht, 2019, Reality and its Order, Springer, Cham.

Heisenberg, Werner, 1927, “Über den anschaulichen Inhalt der quantentheoretischen Kinematik und Mechanik”, in Zeitschrift für Physik, 43: 172-198; Eng. tr.: “The physical content of quantum kinematics and mechanics”, in J.A. Wheeler and W.H. Zurek eds., 1983, Quantum Theory and Measurement, Princeton University Press, Princeton (NJ): 62-84.

Heisenberg, Werner, 1925, “Über quantentheoretische Umdeutung kinematischer und mechanischer Beziehungen”, in Zeitschrift fur Physik, 33: 879-893; Eng. tr.: “Quantum-theoretical re-interpretation of kinematic and mechanical relations”, in Van der Waerden 1967: 261-276.

Husserl, Edmund, 1968, “Umsturz der kopernikanischen Lehre”, Ms. D17, first time published with the title “Grundlegende Untersuchungen zum phänomenologischen Ursprung der Räumlichkeit der Natur”, in M. Farber, ed., Philosophical Essays in Memory of Edmund Husserl, Greenwood Press, New York: 307-325.

Husserl, Edmund, 1954, Die Krisis der europäischen Wissenschaften und die transzendentale Phänomenologie. Eine Einleitung in die phänomenologische Philosophie, Husserliana VI, edited by Walter Biemel, Nijhoff, Den Haag; Eng. tr. by David Carr, The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology. An introduction to Phenomenological Philosophy, Northwestern University Press, Evanston 1970.

Kerszberg, Pierre, 2012, La science dans le monde de la vie, Millon, Paris.

Lewis, Peter J., 2016, Quantum Ontology. A Guide to the Metaphysics of Quantum Mechanics, Oxford University Press, New York.

Lindley, David, 2007, Uncertainty. Einstein, Heisenberg, Bohr, and the Struggle for the Soul of Science, Anchor Books, New York.

Manca, Danilo, 2021, “Spontaneity and givenness: Natorp, Husserl, and Sellars’s Neo-Kantianism”, in Phänomenologische Forschungen, 2: 73-92.

Manca, Danilo, 2016, Esperienza della ragione: Hegel e Husserl in dialogo, Edizioni ETS, Pisa.

Manca, Danilo, 2014, “La scienza allo stato nascente: Merleau-Ponty e Sellars sull’immagine della natura”, in Discipline Filosofiche, 24: 115-136.

Manca, Danilo, and Nunziante, Antonio M., eds., 2020, Discipline Filosofiche, vol. XXX, Realismo, pragmatismo, naturalismo: Le trasformazioni della fenomenologia in Nord America.

Maudlin, David, 2019, Philosophy of physics. Quantum Theory, Princeton University Press, Princeton and Oxford.

Maudlin, David, 2002, Quantum Non-Locality and Relativity. Metaphysical Intimations of Modern Physics, Blackwell, Oxford.

Maudlin, David, 1997, “Descrying the World in the Wave Function”, in The Monist, 80/1: 3-23.

Rovelli, Carlo, 1996, “Relational Quantum Mechanics”, in International Journal of Theoretical Physics, 35/8: 1637-1678.

Rovelli, Carlo, Laudisa, Federico, 2019, “Relational Quantum Mechanics”, in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, <https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-relational/#Bib> (last reading October 1, 2021)

Sachs, Carl, 2020, “Phenomenology vs. the Myth of the Given: A Sellarsian Perspective on Husserl and Merleau-Ponty”, in Manca and Nunziante 2020: 287-301.

Sachs, Carl, 2014, Intentionality and the Myths of the Given: Between Pragmatism and Phenomenology, Routledge, London.

Schrödinger, Erwin, 1928, Collected Papers on Wave Mechanics, Blackie & Son Limited, London and Glascow.

Schrödinger, Erwin, 1926a, “Quantisierung als Eigenwertproblem”, in Annalen der Physik, 79/4: 361-376; 489-527; Eng. tr. “Quantisation as a Problem of Proper Values. Part I and II”, in E. Schrödinger 1928: 1-40.

Schrödinger, Erwin, 1926b, “Über das Verhältnis der Heisenberg-Born-Jordanschen Quantenmechanik zu der meinen”, in Annalen der Physik, 79/4: 734-756; Eng. tr. “On the relation between the Quantum mechanics of Heisenberg, Born, and Jordan”, in E. Schrödinger 1928: 45-61.

Sellars, Wilfrid, 1991, Science, perception and reality, Ridgeview Company, Atascadero, 2nd edition.

Sellars, Wilfrid, 1981a, “Mental Events”, in Philosophical Studies: An International Journal for Philosophy in the Analytic Tradition, 39/4: 325-345

Sellars, Wilfrid, 1981b, “Foundation for a Metaphysics of Pure Process”, in The Monist, 64: 3-90.

Sellars, Wilfrid, 1968, Science and Metaphysics, Routledge & Kegan Paul, New York.

Sellars, Wilfrid, 1962, “Philosophy and the Scientific Image of Man”, now in Sellars 1991: 1-40.

Sellars, Wilfrid, 1961, “The Language of Theories”, now in Sellars 1991: 106-126.

Sellars, Wilfrid, 1956, “Empiricism and the Philosophy of Mind”, now in Sellars 1991: 127-196.

Soffer, Gail, 2003, “Revisiting the Myth: Husserl and Sellars on the Given”, in The Review of Metaphysics, 57: 301-337.

Trizio, Emiliano, 2021, Philosophy’s Nature: Husserl’s Phenomenology, Natural Science, and Metaphysics, Routledge, New York.

Van der Waerden, Bartelt Leendert, ed., 1967, Sources of Quantum Mechanics, Dover Publications, New York.

Van Fraassen, Bas C., 1980, The Scientific Image, Oxford University Press, New York.

Wheeler, John Archibald, Zurek, Wojciech Hubert, 1983, Quantum Theory and Measurement, Princeton University Press, Princeton (NJ).

Wiltsche, Harald A., Berghofer, 2020, Phenomenological Approaches to Physics, Springer, Cham.

Published

2022-03-04

Issue

Section

Focus