Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Analytic Metaphysics should not go

Andrea Strollo

Abstract


Recently, analytic metaphysics has been attacked from a scientist’s perspective. In Everything Must Go, James Ladyman and Don Ross argued that analytic metaphysics should be dismissed and replaced with a naturalized metaphysics. In this paper, I critically discuss the arguments proposed in the book in order to determine whether this critique of analytic metaphysics is successful. In particular, Ladyman and Ross elaborate on three main points: the role of intuitions and the ensuing misunderstanding of science, the demarcation of science from non science, and the exclusive theoretical authority of science. I argue that none of their arguments succeeds in excluding analytic metaphysics from the list of respectable theoretical disciplines.

Keywords


meta-metaphysics; naturalism; Philosophical Methodology;;

Full Text:

PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.